Skip to content

Why is my business experiencing fraud?

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Keep up with the latest on how COVID-19 is affecting retail and how merchants can best continue conducting business in the time of coronavirus


In a nutshell, an ecommerce business starts to experience fraud as they become more visible online.

The combination of advertising campaigns, a rising search engine ranking, and the youth of a store (and perceived inexperience with detecting fraud), makes an online merchant an ideal target for fraudsters.

Let’s explore why this is the case.

When an online merchant opens an ecommerce storefront, they’re entering a vast market, one that is projected to have almost $500 billion in sales by 2018, and is dominated by large players like Amazon, ASOS, Warby Parker and others.

In the beginning, an ecommerce business may generate sales primarily through friends and family. If they intend to grow beyond this small circle, they take steps to increase their visibility and boost traffic, via sales and marketing strategies on variety of channels, all designed to drive customers to their site and create sales. (For example, a common strategy is using Facebook Ads to target a particular demographic, or buying keywords from Google AdWords.)

If the business is successful in their strategies, they’ve generated an increase in traffic by customers interested in purchasing their product. As a result of this increase in traffic, their search engine ranking rises. (Alexa is a common tool that lists site rankings.)

But with the increased visibility comes an unwanted new type of customer, a fraudster.

Why am I getting hit with fraud now?

As an ecommerce site’s SEO ranking increases, due to marketing and advertising efforts, the online store is simply easier to be found than it was previously. For better, and for worse, the plan to grab more visitors worked, and some of the visitors aren’t good.

Fraudsters are aware of the fact that established online stores have online fraud protection measures. Typically, the larger the corporation, the more robust the security set-up, and the more experienced they are at detecting and preventing fraudulent orders.

The same usually can’t be said for new ecommerce companies, who likely have little to no awareness of the true complexities of online fraud and what a fraudulent order looks like. This, combined with a new online merchant’s eagerness to accept orders, translates into great opportunity for fraudsters.

Larger stores expect to cancel a certain number of orders due to their riskiness and potential for fraud, but the same mindset typically isn’t there for new or smaller ecommerce merchants. Cancelling even a single order for a new company can be a distressing decision, as they’re understandably eager to collect the sale and grow their business. Fraudsters seek to prey on the companies who most need the cash to grow, because they recognize how desperate small companies are for business. As a result, they’re constantly looking for the next new online store to exploit.

Why do new or small online merchants fail to identify fraud?

New and smaller merchants generally have two factors working against them: a lack of experience detecting fraudulent orders and a lack of resources to dedicate a full-time employee to reviewing orders.

These merchants often find themselves out of their depth when it comes to fraud, as they lack the scope of experience their larger competitors have. Indeed, the thousands of hours spent differentiating between a good order and a bad one makes a much bigger company more effective at identifying common fraudulent patterns in the future, and preventing acceptance of bad orders.

Plus, if the merchant does flag an order as possibly suspicious, they may not know how to properly investigate, and which pieces of data they should give more credence to than others. For example, without experience in order review, a new or small online merchant may default to simply calling the customer on the order to clarify certain items, as they lack the knowledge that a smart fraudster is more than willing to answer a phone call.

On top of that, considering many online merchants simply don’t have the financial resources to dedicate staff (or hire an experienced professional) to order review, they are unfortunately a ripe target for continuing fraudulent attacks.

Can I stop fraud?

The only way to stop fraud on a site is to stop selling.

But, as that’s often out of the question, online merchants will have to turn to selling smarter, and adapting the mindset of larger competitors. As painful as it is, expect to not accept all of your orders. Expect that fraud will occur, and start preparing your organization to deal with it. Depending on your resources, you will have a few options, from improving order review efficiency and effectiveness in-house to using a vendor with fraud expertise to handle order review entirely.

In the world of online fraud, the best defense is a good offense. Start building your offense now.


Signifyd provides an end-to-end Commerce Protection Platform that leverages its Commerce Network to maximize conversion, automate customer experience and eliminate fraud and customer abuse for retailers. Signifyd counts among its customers a number of companies on the Fortune 1000 and Internet Retailer Top 500 lists. Signifyd is headquartered in San Jose, CA., with locations in Denver, New York, Belfast, and London.